MagicSLD2458
Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief
Mythic
Non-foil
TCGplayer Non-foil
4.23 $
Cardmarket Non-foil
—
eBay Non-foil
—
Foil
TCGplayer Foil
4.23 $
Cardmarket Foil
—
eBay Foil
—
My collection
Normal
0
Foil
0
- Number
- 2458
- Released
- June 23, 2026
Description
Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief (2458) currently sells for around 4.23 $ on TCGplayer, the cheapest of the two marketplaces we track (Cardmarket 7.23 €). Its TCGplayer price is down 10% over the last 3 months. Mythic card from Secret Lair Drop Series (Magic), released on June 23, 2026.
Prices by marketplace
TCGplayer
View on TCGplayerPrice history
Market price (last 6 months)| Variant | Lowest price | Market price | Highest price |
|---|---|---|---|
| NormalNear Mint · 25+ listings | 3.20 $ | 4.23 $ | 5.75 $ |
| FoilNear Mint · 25+ listings | 3.23 $ | 4.23 $ | 5.76 $ |
Prices by condition and listings
Normal
| Condition | Lowest price | Market price | Listings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Near MintNM | 3.20 $ | 4.23 $ | 25+ |
| Lightly PlayedLP | 3.00 $ | 4.22 $ | 17 |
| DamagedDMG | 3.44 $ | 3.44 $ | 1 |
No listing in MP, HP
Foil
| Condition | Lowest price | Market price | Listings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Near MintNM | 3.23 $ | 4.23 $ | 25+ |
| Lightly PlayedLP | 2.49 $ | 3.95 $ | 25+ |
| Moderately PlayedMP | 4.49 $ | 4.49 $ | 1 |
No listing in HP, DMG
Listing count from the TCGplayer price guide, condition by condition, capped at 25 ("25+" means 25 or more). It can be lower than the total shown on the TCGplayer page, which counts every active offer.
Cardmarket Cardmarket prices are being fine-tuned. If a price looks too far off compared to the other platforms, please disregard it for now. Thanks
View on CardmarketPrice history
Cardmarket price (last 6 months)Lowest price6.71 €
Price trend7.23 €
7-day average7.24 €
30-day average7.20 €
eBay
View on eBayPrice history
eBay median price (last 6 months)Lowest listing4.95 $
Average listing10.27 $
Median price7.99 $
Listings found7
View analysed listings
Used in the calculation
- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief SLD #2458 - MTG Foil NM6.95 $
- Benny, Platinum Thief #2458 Tinybones, Trinket Thief (NM) (Non-Foil) Magic MTG7.99 $
- Benny Platinum Thief Tinybones Trinket 2458 Non Foil MTG NM Secret Lair Fallout7.95 $
- Benny, Platinum Thief Tinybones Trinket MTG SLD 2458 Mythic NM Fallout Discard12.99 $
- MTG Fallout SLD *Foil Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief 2458 M16.90 $
- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief - FOIL - 2458 Secret Lair MTG14.19 $
- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief SLD 2458 Secret Lair Drop Se...4.95 $
Excluded
- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief (Foil) NM Secret Lair Drop7.79 $ · missing_card_number
- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief FOIL Secret Lair Drop Series7.99 $ · missing_card_number
- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief Secret Lair Drop Foil8.00 $ · missing_card_number
- BENNY PLATINUM THIEF (TINYBONES TRINKET THIEF) MTG FOIL SECRET LAIR FALLOUT 6.80 $ · missing_card_number
- MTG English Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief NM Foil Secret Lair5.49 $ · missing_card_number
- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief - Near Mint MTG Secret Lair10.30 $ · missing_card_number
- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief Secret Lair Drop MTG Foil NM12.99 $ · missing_card_number
- Tinybones, Trinket Thief - Benny, Platinum Thief - MTG SLD x Fallout non-foil7.99 $ · missing_card_number
- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief - Foil NM MTG Secret Lair Dr...8.49 $ · missing_card_number
- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket T... [SLD] NM MTG Magic the Gathering17.84 $ · missing_card_number
- MTG x Fallout: New Vegas - Benny, Platinum Thief (Tinybones, Trinket Thief) FOIL13.37 $ · missing_card_number
- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trin... [SLD] NM Foil MTG Magic the Gathering19.94 $ · missing_name
- MTG Foil Benny, Platinum Thief Borderless Tinybones Trinket Thief Secret Lair NM14.83 $ · missing_card_number
- MTG Benny, Platinum Thief- Tinybones, Trinket Thief Secret Lair Drop Foil Mythic13.99 $ · missing_card_number
- PRESALE- Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief FOIL - MTG Secret Lair14.50 $ · missing_card_number
- Benny Platinum Thief Secret Lair x Fallout HOLO FOIL: Welcome to New vegasMTG NM10.00 $ · missing_name
- MTG Benny, Platinum Thief Borderless Tinybones Trinket Thief Secret Lair NM14.43 $ · missing_card_number
- Tinybones Trinket Thief - Benny ✨ Borderless FOIL ✨ MTG FALLOUT Secret Lair 245819.99 $ · missing_name
- MTG Benny, Platinum Thief - Tinybones, Trinket Thief Secret Lair Drop Reg Mythic12.49 $ · missing_card_number
- Secret Lair x Fallout: Welcome to New Vegas - Benny, Platinum Thief 2458 MTG SLD8.97 $ · missing_name
Completed sales View sold on eBay
